
<p>Inspired by <a href="https://twitter.com/antbejarano/status/1216952452349448192" rel="nofollow">a member query</a>, we looked into the best years for Academy Award Best Picture nominees by average rating. (Updated on December 23, 2025.)</p><p>2019 certainly felt like a great film year for highly rated Best Picture finalists (indeed, all of the finalists in the 92nd Academy Awards are in our <a href="https://boxd.it/8HjM" rel="nofollow">Official Top 250 Narrative Feature Films</a>), but when we ran the data on 560* Best Picture-nominated films across 92 years of Academy Awards history, the year 1975 (awarded at the 48th Academy Awards in March 1976) was the winner by a decent margin. Time for medicine!</p><p>Each year’s lineup is represented in the list below by its highest-rated film. In the notes, you’ll find the overall average rating and the other finalists for that year. The winner for each year is marked with a trophy. There are no ties—we compute the average for each year to several decimal places, but they are rounded to 2dp below.</p><p><b>Statistics of Interest</b><br />— The 1970s is the highest-ranked decade overall, with a 3.94 average rating across all nominated pictures.<br />— The 2010s was a strong decade, with 44 films making <a href="https://boxd.it/4oQEC" rel="nofollow">our top 250 of the decade</a> (exactly half of that decade’s nominees).<br />— There was no obvious advantage or disadvantage for years with expanded Best Picture lineups.<br />— The overall average of all Best Picture nominees is 3.74.<br />— You agreed with the Academy on the Best Picture winner in just 25 of 95 ceremonies.</p><p>*We excluded lost and partially lost films. Ernst Lubitsch’s <i><a href="https://boxd.it/2XhS" rel="nofollow">The Patriot</a></i> (1928) is the only lost film that is impossible to see (Letterboxd members have mostly rated its trailer). <i><a href="https://boxd.it/2Xxc" rel="nofollow">The White Parade</a></i> (1934) is only available at UCLA’s laboratories and has yet to be restored and publicly screened. <i><a href="https://boxd.it/2XYW" rel="nofollow">East Lynne</a></i> (1931) is available but the final reel is lost. We also excluded the nominees for Best Unique and Artistic Picture at the first Academy Awards (<i>Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans, Chang, The Crowd</i>) because the Academy doesn’t recognize the category as part of its Best Picture history.</p><p><a href="https://letterboxd.com/grogg/list/academy-award-nominees-for-best-picture/" rel="nofollow">Here’s a handy list</a> of all films nominated for Best Picture. All numbers crunched by <a href="https://letterboxd.com/jack/" rel="nofollow">Jack Moulton</a> and Letterboxd HQ.</p>
Number of Movies
97