

Following the events of the previous film, Zoe survived the yule log's attack, but Alex was killed. Police believe they were attacked by Pleatherface, disbelieving Zoe's story about the yule log being sentient or the other supernatural events that occurred. The yule log breaks out of the evidence locker, setting off an explosion that destroys Alex's video evidence. Believing the log is after her, Zoe has a panic attack during a client meeting, and is fired from her job at the Coral Conservancy. Her friend Jakesy consoles her and pushes her to go on vacation and break out of her horror movie past into a cheery "Hallmark"-style romantic comedy. As they drive, Santa Claus observes them and uses his magic to stall their car in the small town of Mistletoe, where Zoe experiences shifts from the dreary horror movie setting into a lighter and more cheerful Christmas movie, complete with happy music and brighter cinematographic palette. A local mechanic tells them that it will take several days to fix the car and that the town is set to celebrate its annual Yule Log Festival.